Zarina Subhan, an experienced teacher and teacher trainer, tackles the second of our Solutions Speaking Challenges: “My students say the absolute minimum”.
I find myself in the classroom in an unfamiliar position. It’s not the fact that I’ve given up teaching that makes this a new experience for me. It is the fact that I’m a student again. I’m learning Spanish and am sitting behind the desk, no longer the decision-maker who tells the learners what to do, but the student awaiting instructions and wondering if I understood them.
I’m rediscovering how uncertain, vulnerable and anxious it can feel to be a language student. Most of the reading, writing, listening, speaking and (most importantly) thinking in the target language (TL) happens in the classroom. I know I am there to improve my language; my motivation as an adult learner is high, yet I have to admit I could speak more in Spanish. So why don’t I?
The PPP Model
When you think you’ve grasped the structure of the language that has been presented, it is quite demoralising when you ‘practise’ it and get it all confused, or if you get the grammar focus right you somehow lose all previously-learned knowledge of the language.
When it is my turn to speak I keep babbling on about whatever it is that I’m attempting to say. The natural thing for the teacher to do is to correct me. However, as soon as s/he corrects me it interrupts me. I’m trying so hard to concentrate on what I have to say that this correction stops my thinking, when I need every single brain cell to be able to speak. It has taken me a great deal of focused thinking, recalling, structuring and motivation to construct and actually produce that language. Instead of feeling pleased about having actually communicated in the TL, I focus on what I failed to say correctly.
So, what if I could write a letter advising my teacher what would I say?
Letter to my teacher
- Please wait until I’ve completed what it is I want to say, then focus on the idea I communicated and show me you’ve understood.
That would really give me a feeling of success rather than failure. If at the end you could praise me and only correct me in terms of the structure/language/topic that is the focus for the lesson, it would help me turn your extrinsic motivation into my intrinsic motivation, and help me feel better about opening my mouth again in future.
- Could you also not insist on us taking turns one after the other to speak?
I stop listening to my classmates until it’s just before my turn, when I tune back into the lesson. Perhaps if you asked for volunteers – the ones who actually have something interesting/fun to say – it would be more interesting for the rest of us and it wouldn’t be as painful as ALL of us reading out our boring, unimaginative offerings.
- If you gave us more than 2 seconds to come up with a response to your questions it would give me more thinking time.
Please count to 10, or say the same thing a slightly different way. Whatever you do, don’t translate it, don’t ask several questions all at once, and don’t give us the answer before anyone has attempted to offer a response! Instead try writing up the key words of your question, show me a visual cue, and remind me when I last used this word/phrase. This all boosts my confidence and gives me more time to figure out my response rather than spending half my thinking time trying to be sure I’ve understood you correctly.
- I’ve noticed that when we have a laugh, I can forget about my anxiety and about being wrong/not being understood.
So how about if we have points/smiley stickers/competitive games between teams – so that every time we give you a response in the TL we gain an advantage for our team? It may seem childish to you, but actually my wish to win/gain points/stickers overcomes the anxiety I sometimes feel and motivates me to speak.
- Talking of anxiety, not everyone likes speaking in front of the whole class.
If you moved around the class and came to individual groups/pairs, we would feel happier speaking to each other with you listening in. Then you can correct us individually in a more intimate situation and not with everyone listening.
My lack of speaking is nothing personal. My lack of speaking is simply because I don’t like looking a fool in front of others. So I’d really appreciate it if you could eliminate the thinking that making mistakes is foolish and encourage the attitude that having a go is courageous. I think, then, I would be a better speaker in your classes.
15 April 2014 at
Reblogged this on TESOL_Peter and commented:
This is great advice to the language teacher! I certainly agree with everything here but I am a little wary of giving stickers unless it is given sparingly. My answer to the forth point is to tell jokes in class if you are the teacher, particularly jokes that involve both L1 and L2 words. It could help students remember certain vocabulary if it is presented in a pun. But don’t overdo it though. My colleagues can attest to this!
15 April 2014 at
Reblogged this on amengental.
15 April 2014 at
Well interesting read here of the “teacher-cum student” saga. As uncle Albert (Einstein) said (simply): everything is relative”… . .and undeniably IS:). .. . . I’m a very active ESL teacher and i like to think i’m helping students in the classroom, not putting more burden on their already difficult task!!!!
16 April 2014 at
Reblogged this on hungarywolf.
17 April 2014 at
Very good article indeed. Let students talk and do make mistakes, there’s no other/better way to improve their speaking skills. We have to be patient, that’s it.
Pingback: My students say the absolute minimum | English ...
14 May 2014 at
Reblogged this on Ambitious ELT and commented:
An amazing piece by Zarina Subhan that might make us all a little bit more aware of our bad habits as ELTs
14 May 2014 at
Amazing, I completely agree and I wrote a similar blog post myself this morning, right down to the studying Spanish 🙂 http://hartlelearning.wordpress.com/2014/05/14/do-learners-want-to-speak-english-or-not/
16 May 2014 at
As an English teacher, I find all this very interesting and useful. Moreover, I’m currently learning Spanish online. Even when I am alone, I feel it upsetting to repeat works or sentences, or to speak Spanish in front of the computer. I feel ridiculous !
17 May 2014 at
Reblogged this on Halina's Thoughts and commented:
Pingback: Useful links for CELTA | Sandy Millin